Resistance is on the March

This past weekend, we joined the March for Science in St Louis – and on social media got to see other marches from all over the world.  The numbers in DC, Chicago, Boston and other big cities were impressive, but equally, if not more so, were the turnouts in smaller cities and towns across the US, and the pictures sent in from Guam, Arctic research stations, and Wake Atoll in the Pacific.  Science for the purposes of these marches was defined as broadly as it could be, as it should be.  Paleontologists, geologists, physicists and chemists, engineers and math teachers, sociologists and climate scientists were all there – and many more whose signs didn’t proclaim their area.  One sign read “Without Science, It’s Just Fiction” and there were Dr Who and Star Trek fans (and actors) there to bear witness. Of course, I particularly noticed the medical sciences and the signs calling out the impact of vaccines and other medical advances on human health. I also learned a new and creative use for old posters! While I didn’t see any signs specifically referencing infection prevention or hospital epidemiology, I liked the sign reading “Microbiologists Support All Cultures” and was struck by the one that said “Even the Bacteria Are Resisting…”

            That last sign of course turns the concept of resistance in a different direction, but that kind of resistance is also “on the march” (stick with me here).  A recent research letter in EID by Perez and colleagues used VHA microbiology data to map the spread of carbapenem-resistance (CR) in Klebsiella pneumoniae  and Enterobacter cloacae complex across the US from 2006 – 2015.  In an excellent example of the value of VHA data, the maps show what the authors call a ‘second epidemic’ of CR – Enterobacter.  Unlike CR-Klebsiella which started in the northeast and spread west and south,  CR-Enterobacter was detected in both northeast and almost simultaneously in west coast VHA facilities.  From there, it spread to meet in the middle of the south, by 2015 sparing only a few states. The percentage of E cloacae isolates with carbapenem resistance rose steadily over the study period.  The figures are sobering.

My cousin asked me, gently, whether I thought the science marches “changed any minds”, or were just another way of  “preaching to the choir”.  My answer was no, I don't think minds were changed by the march.  I’m not sure “changing minds” was even the goal.  I told him I hoped the marches drew attention to how large the field of “science” is, and how many supporters it has.  I hoped it drew that attention from legislators and politicians contemplating budget priorities and funding cuts.  I hoped the marches pointed out how many people would be watching those decisions carefully and asking for explanations by phone call, postcard and at town hall meetings.  Because the march of both kinds of resistance continues – and how we respond has serious consequences. 


  1. Wow! A non-Iowan AND female blogger!
    Looking forward to reading your posts Hilary!!!
    PS. Milwaukee marched too. Great experience

  2. Welcome Hilary - great post! Just to clarify, none of us are Iowan and only one lived in Iowa when the blog started. When Andreas Voss gave his social media talk at ECCMID on Monday and mentioned that Hilary was added to the blogroll, the "Reflections" bloggers (Otter, Kiernan, Voss) all came up to me and mentioned how happy they were that there was a female voice. So there was trans-atlantic happiness - rare these days.


Post a Comment

Thanks for submitting your comment to the Controversies blog. To reduce spam, all comments will be reviewed by the blog moderator prior to publishing. However, all legitimate comments will be published, whether they agree with or oppose the content of the post.

Most Read Posts (Last 30 Days)