Does #OpenAccess increase readership?
From the "I Wish I Did This Study" department. Philip Davis and the American Physiological Society completed an RCT of the open-access publication model. All articles published in 11 APS journals between January and April 2007 were randomized into immediate free access (n=247) or normal subscription-only access for the first 12 months (n=1372). So did it work? Yes - far more downloads, same number of citations.
Article downloads: One-year after publication, open access articles received twice the number of full-text downloads and 61% more PDF downloads with more unique visitors. Fewer looked at the abstract with open-access, but why would they when they can read the whole thing? (see figure below)
Citations: Open-access articles were cited in similar numbers. During the first year, 71% of open-access and 74% of subscription articles were cited at least once. At three years, citations averaged 10.6 per open-access and 10.7 per subscription-based article.
My only question. Why was this published in a newsletter and not a peer-reviewed journal?
Reference: PM Davis. Physiologist. 2010 Dec;53(6):197, 200-1.
Yes, I know this discussion isn't specific to infection prevention, but it is a "controversy" so I'm at least partially sticking to our mission. (insert emoticon)
Article downloads: One-year after publication, open access articles received twice the number of full-text downloads and 61% more PDF downloads with more unique visitors. Fewer looked at the abstract with open-access, but why would they when they can read the whole thing? (see figure below)
Citations: Open-access articles were cited in similar numbers. During the first year, 71% of open-access and 74% of subscription articles were cited at least once. At three years, citations averaged 10.6 per open-access and 10.7 per subscription-based article.
My only question. Why was this published in a newsletter and not a peer-reviewed journal?
Reference: PM Davis. Physiologist. 2010 Dec;53(6):197, 200-1.
Yes, I know this discussion isn't specific to infection prevention, but it is a "controversy" so I'm at least partially sticking to our mission. (insert emoticon)
Comments
Post a Comment
Thanks for submitting your comment to the Controversies blog. To reduce spam, all comments will be reviewed by the blog moderator prior to publishing. However, all legitimate comments will be published, whether they agree with or oppose the content of the post.