San Francisco Lab Worker Dies of Lab-acquired Meningococcus
There is a very sad report in today's San Jose Mercury News concerning a 25-year old associate at the San Francisco VA Medical Center's Northern California Institute for Research and Education (NCIRE) who'd been working on a vaccine for Neisseria meningitidis, serogroup B. The lab work is very important, since vaccines for most of the other
major disease-causing serogroups (C, Y, W135, and A) have been developed
and licensed in the US.
He apparently left work Friday evening without symptoms but two hours later felt feverish with a headache. By Saturday morning he had a rash and arrested in the car ride to the hospital. California-OSHA and CDC are investigating the case and have already confirmed that the strain he was infected with was the same serogroup B strain that the lab was studying.
Unfortunately, lab-acquired infections do occur with some frequency. The most memorable case for me was the report of a grad student in Singapore that was working on West Nile Virus yet became infected with SARS-CoV that had somehow contaminated his West Nile samples.
A few years ago (2009), Kamaljit Singh published a very nice review in CID covering microbiology lab-acquired infections. Most of the data included in the review are old, with the included frequency data from 1976 and 1978. However, I've pasted table 2 below, which highlights the relative risk of specific infections in lab workers compared to the general public. After Brucella, N. meningitidis appears to be the second highest risk with a RR=40.8. The review also discusses the 16 cases reported between 1985 and 2001 and highlights the importance of tetravalent vaccine for all laboratory microbiologists. Sadly, that wouldn't have helped in this case.
Addendum: Updated report from SF Chronicle this morning (May 3) and local ABC affiliate report. Name released and investigation uncovers lack of vaccination among workers (KQED). note: vaccination would have been ineffective in this case.
He apparently left work Friday evening without symptoms but two hours later felt feverish with a headache. By Saturday morning he had a rash and arrested in the car ride to the hospital. California-OSHA and CDC are investigating the case and have already confirmed that the strain he was infected with was the same serogroup B strain that the lab was studying.
Unfortunately, lab-acquired infections do occur with some frequency. The most memorable case for me was the report of a grad student in Singapore that was working on West Nile Virus yet became infected with SARS-CoV that had somehow contaminated his West Nile samples.
A few years ago (2009), Kamaljit Singh published a very nice review in CID covering microbiology lab-acquired infections. Most of the data included in the review are old, with the included frequency data from 1976 and 1978. However, I've pasted table 2 below, which highlights the relative risk of specific infections in lab workers compared to the general public. After Brucella, N. meningitidis appears to be the second highest risk with a RR=40.8. The review also discusses the 16 cases reported between 1985 and 2001 and highlights the importance of tetravalent vaccine for all laboratory microbiologists. Sadly, that wouldn't have helped in this case.
Addendum: Updated report from SF Chronicle this morning (May 3) and local ABC affiliate report. Name released and investigation uncovers lack of vaccination among workers (KQED). note: vaccination would have been ineffective in this case.
Comments
Post a Comment
Thanks for submitting your comment to the Controversies blog. To reduce spam, all comments will be reviewed by the blog moderator prior to publishing. However, all legitimate comments will be published, whether they agree with or oppose the content of the post.